You’ve put in the work. You’ve created something valuable — a community space that complements your content, deepens your audience connection, and offers real support and transformation.
You’re proud of it. Excited, even.
But then people start joining… and you notice a pattern.
They pop in, maybe click around, maybe say hi. Then? Silence.
You’re left wondering:
Was the value not clear? Did they not know what to do? Was it too overwhelming?
If this sounds familiar, you’re not alone. Most content creators don’t struggle to get members — they struggle to activate them.
And in almost every case, the problem isn’t your content or your offer. It’s your onboarding.
If you want your community to thrive, you need more than a welcome message. You need a system — one that guides new members through those crucial first moments and turns them from passive browsers into active participants.
In this post, I’ll show you how to build that system — and what to include in your onboarding flow to make sure your members stick around, engage, and get value from your space right away.
🎯 What Great Onboarding Really Does
Most people don’t join an online community because they’re bored — they join because they want something: connection, clarity, momentum, or transformation. But even when they’re genuinely interested, many new members stall out within the first few days.
Not because your content isn’t great. Not because your community isn’t valuable.
But because they’re unsure what to do next — or don’t feel confident stepping in.
That’s where great onboarding comes in.
Think of it as your community’s front door and first impression.
It doesn’t just welcome people in — it shows them how to belong.
Here’s what effective onboarding actually does:
It reduces friction. New platforms can feel disorienting. A good onboarding flow removes guesswork and tells members exactly where to go and what to do first.
It builds confidence. Instead of feeling like outsiders, new members get a clear sense of how to participate — and what kind of contributions are encouraged.
It creates quick wins. Whether it’s completing their profile, posting an intro, or accessing their first resource, onboarding should give members small early victories that keep them moving forward.
It forms lasting habits. The actions you guide members through in the first few days (like checking in, commenting, or joining events) become behaviors they’re more likely to repeat over time.
It sets expectations and culture. From the language you use to the actions you promote, onboarding signals what kind of space this is — and what kind of energy you want members to bring.
Bottom line? Onboarding isn’t just a formality. It’s the foundation of a thriving community.
If you design it with intention, you’ll turn casual signups into invested contributors — and start building the kind of momentum that doesn’t depend on you being online 24/7.
1. Create a ‘Start Here’ Space That Teaches Habits
Every community needs a clear, visible entry point — a place that not only welcomes members but shows them how to engage.
That’s what your Start Here space is for. It sets the tone, gives members confidence, and helps them take meaningful action from day one.
Start with a short welcome video (2–3 minutes) introducing yourself, the purpose of the community, and how things are organized. Keep the tone warm and personal — this is your chance to make people feel like they belong here.
From there, guide them through a few key habits that will help them get the most out of the space:
Set up your profile (photo, bio, social links) so people know who you are
Turn on notifications for important spaces or threads
Post your questions publicly, not in DMs or email — it helps everyone learn
Check in weekly or follow specific spaces to stay in the loop
You don’t need to overwhelm them with everything all at once. Just give them the tools — and the encouragement — to participate confidently.
If your members leave this space feeling welcomed, informed, and clear on what to do next, onboarding has already started off on the right foot.
2. Build an Onboarding Course or ‘New Member Challenge’
While a “Start Here” space gives new members the lay of the land, an onboarding course turns orientation into action.
This doesn’t need to be a full-blown curriculum — think of it more like a guided checklist, broken into bite-sized lessons that help members engage step by step.
You can frame it as a “New Member Challenge” to make it feel more interactive and rewarding.
Each lesson should cover one simple action, such as:
✅ Set up your profile
✅ Download the mobile app (if applicable)
✅ Introduce yourself in the community
✅ Join your first event or comment on a thread
✅ Bookmark or follow your favorite space
✅ Read the community guidelines
Spacing these out into a course or challenge format helps reduce overwhelm while encouraging consistent progress. You’re not just telling people what to do — you’re walking them through it in a way that builds confidence.
Bonus: use completion tracking or gamified language (e.g. “You’re 80% onboarded!”) to make progress feel tangible. When people feel a sense of movement early on, they’re much more likely to stick around and keep participating.
3. Offer a Welcome Package as a Reward
If you want more people to actually complete your onboarding flow, give them a reason to follow through — beyond just “knowing how the community works.”
A simple welcome package can be a powerful motivator. It rewards early action, builds goodwill, and reinforces the idea that your community delivers value from day one.
This doesn’t have to be elaborate or high-budget. The best welcome packages are quick wins that feel exclusive, useful, or just a little bit special. For example:
🎁 A downloadable resource pack
🔑 A members-only discount code
🧰 Access to bonus templates, playlists, or swipe files
🎟️ An invite to a private event, workshop, or office hour
Tie the package to onboarding completion — for example, after they finish your new member challenge or submit a short form. This adds a clear goal to work toward and gives you an opportunity to celebrate them for showing up.
It’s not about bribing participation — it’s about reinforcing a positive first experience and rewarding momentum. And when members feel seen and appreciated early on, they’re far more likely to stay engaged.
4. Send a Personal Welcome DM + Survey
One of the simplest ways to make a new member feel seen? Send them a message the moment they join.
Whether automated or manual, a personal welcome DM helps cut through the noise and makes the experience feel human — especially in the early days of your community when every new connection counts.
Keep the message short, warm, and intentional. Include three key things:
A quick welcome (in your natural tone of voice)
A nudge to complete the onboarding or “Start Here” flow
A link to a short welcome survey
The survey serves two purposes:
It helps you understand who’s joining, what they’re looking for, and how you can support them
It gives the member a chance to reflect and commit to the journey they’re starting inside your space
Want to boost completion rates? Frame it like this:
“Fill this out and I’ll send you a custom step-plan for getting the most out of the space — especially helpful if you’re not sure where to begin.”
It’s a small touch that goes a long way. When people feel like you’re paying attention to them, they’re much more likely to stick around and contribute — not just consume.
5. Send a Welcome Email That Drives Action
A new member joins your community — and shortly after, they get an email from you.
This moment matters. For many people, that email is their first real interaction with your brand outside of your platform. If it’s forgettable, they may never log back in.
That’s why every welcome email should have one clear goal:
Get them back into the community and taking action.
Skip the long story or overly formal intro. Focus on reinforcing their decision to join and guiding them toward a small, meaningful next step.
Here’s what to include:
A short, friendly welcome — in your voice
A reminder of what they now have access to (community, resources, courses, etc.)
A strong call-to-action:
→ “Start the new member challenge”
→ “Introduce yourself here”
→ “Download your welcome package”
→ “Watch the 2-minute welcome video”
It’s also a great moment to restate your bigger vision: why you created the space, who it’s for, and how they’ll benefit by getting involved.
Remember, the email isn’t the destination — the community is. Your job is to gently nudge them back into the platform where real connection and momentum begin.
⚠️ Common Mistakes to Avoid
Even well-intentioned communities lose momentum if the onboarding isn’t thoughtfully designed. Here are a few common traps I see creators fall into — and what to do instead:
1. Overloading new members with too much too fast
It’s tempting to show them everything right away. But long lists of links, dense explanations, or multiple calls to action can overwhelm more than they help. Stick to 1–2 clear next steps at a time.
2. Hiding key onboarding content
If your “Start Here” space is buried halfway down your navigation — or not clearly labeled — it’s likely to be missed. Make sure it’s easy to find, easy to follow, and impossible to ignore.
3. Making first actions feel too high-effort
Asking for a lengthy intro post, a full profile build-out, or course enrollment right away can cause drop-off. Start with small wins that build confidence — and stack deeper engagement later.
4. Leaving new members in silence
If someone joins and never hears from you — no DM, no email, no prompt — they’re unlikely to come back. Onboarding should feel interactive, not passive.
5. Treating onboarding as a one-time task
Good onboarding is more than a welcome message — it’s a guided experience that unfolds over days or weeks. Use reminders, follow-ups, and engagement prompts to keep new members moving forward.
Onboarding doesn’t need to be complicated — but it does need to be intentional. Avoid these pitfalls, and you’ll create an experience that not only welcomes new members, but turns them into active, long-term contributors.
🧠 TL;DR: The Onboarding Stack
Here’s a quick recap of what your onboarding system should include:
✅ A ‘Start Here’ space with a welcome video and simple habits
✅ An onboarding course or new member challenge
✅ A welcome package to incentivize completion
✅ A personal welcome DM + survey
✅ A welcome email that drives platform engagement
Together, these tools create clarity, momentum, and a sense of belonging from day one.
And that’s what gets people to stay.
Ready to Make Your Community More Engaging?
If you’re tired of guessing what to post to get members talking, my Engagement Prompt Pack takes out the guesswork.
It includes 30+ days worth of proven prompts designed to boost conversations, connection, and activity in your community — without you having to post every day.